| Postion | Player | Team |
| Face 1 | ||
| Lou Burdette | Milwaukee Braves | |
| Al Kaline - Tigers | Detroit Tigers | |
| Bob Grim | NY Yankees | |
| Jim Turner - coach | NY Yankees | |
| Bill Skowron - Yankees | NY Yankees | |
| Don Mossi - Indians | Cleveland Indians | |
| Face 2 | ||
| Bob Richardson - Yankees | NY Yankees | |
| Roy Sievers - Senators | Washington Senators | |
| Frank Malzone - Red Sox | Boston Red Sox | |
| Jim Bunning - Tigers | Detroit Tigers | |
| Minnie Minoso - White Sox | Chicago White Sox | |
| Bill Loes - Orioles | Baltimore Orioles | |
| Early Wynn - Indians | Cleveland Indians | |
| Geo Kell - Orioles | Baltimore Orioles | |
| Face 3 | ||
| Alex Kellner | KC Athletics | |
| Yogi Berra - Yankees | NY Yankees | |
| Joe DeMaestri - Athletics | KC Athletics | |
| Bobby Shantz - Yankees | NY Yankees | |
| Charlie Maxwell - Tigers | Detroit Tigers | |
| Harvey Kuenn - Tigers | Detroit Tigers | |
| Face 4 | ||
| Gus Triandos - Orioles | Baltimore Orioles | |
| Nelson Fox - White Sox | Chicago White Sox | |
| Elston Howard - Yankees | NY Yankees | |
| Gil McDougal | NY Yankees | |
| Sweet Spot | ||